› Ask yourself:
This page explores the controversy surrounding the historiography and recognition of the Armenian genocide. Use the timeline and the primary and secondary sources below to understand the arguments of genocide "believers" and "deniers," as well as the importance of genocide recognition for the Armenians, and the reluctance of many countries to call the events of 1915 “a genocide”.
Genocide: The deliberate and systematic destruction of an ethnic, racial, caste, religious, or national group.
Historiography: The writing of historical events that produces a written history.
Ottoman Empire (1453-1922): An Islamic empire that stretched from Eastern Europe to North Africa and became completely dissolved when modern Turkey was formed.
Sublime Porte: The central government in the Ottoman Empire.
Millet System: The Ottoman Empire was organized into millets based on religion. While Muslim millets enjoyed the most freedoms, those in Christian millets, such as Armenians, were seen as secondary citizen Citizens and faced higher taxation.
Hamidiye: A semi-regular regiment of Kurdish and Circassian horsemen organized by Sultan Hamid II to suppress Armenian rebellions in the Ottoman Empire.
The Young Turks: A Turkish reform organization promising to replace the disorder and corruption under the Sultan’s reign with a constitutional government where all Ottoman citizens would be equal.
The Committee of Union and Progress: A branch of the Young Turk organization that assassinated Sultan Hamid II.
The Young Turk Triumvirate: An ultra-nationalist government led by Mehmed Talaat, Ismail Enver, and Ahmed Djemal. Together they took control of the original Young Turk government and promoted Pan-Turkism instead of equality.
Pan-Turkism: An ideology seeking the construction of a Turkish empire stretching from Anatolia into Central Asia and whose population would be exclusively Turkic instead of Ottoman.
Turkification: A process attempting to destroy non-Turkic cultures through assimilation or removal.
Shotas: A special organization gang trained and equipped by the Young Turk triumvirate to assist with the round-up of the Armenians and to disrupt the deportation process by looting, ravaging, and killing Armenians en route.
Source: The Genocide Education Project, Human Rights and Genocide, 2005.
Credit: (Reproduction Number: LC-DIG-ggbain-29847 (digital file from original negative) Rights Information: No known restrictions on publication.) This media file is in the public domain in the United States. This applies to U.S. works where the copyright has expired, often because its first publication occurred prior to January 1, 1923.
“The aim of war is not to reach definite lines, but to annihilate the enemy physically. After all, who today still speaks of the massacre of the Armenians?”
It was Hitler who told this to his military officers a week before Nazi Germany invaded Poland and brought the world into war for a second time. But what exactly did Hitler mean when stating this? Especially when referring to the massacre of the Armenians?
As historian Peter Balkian explains, Hitler is recalling what many refer to as “the forgotten genocide” or “hidden holocaust” of the Armenians that began in 1915. The genocide resulted in the death of approximately 1.5 million Armenians in the Ottoman Empire and has left many of its survivors scattered worldwide. But wait, you might ask, “wasn’t the Jewish Holocaust the first genocide of the 20th century?” This really depends on whom you ask. The Armenian genocide is one of the most contested genocides in history and is still being debated today—almost a century later. However, before we dive deeper into the controversy around the genocide, let’s take a step back and explore the Turkish and Armenian past by examining the timeline on the next page. For a more comprehensive timeline visit the following websites:
So where does the controversy lie? It lies in two divergent and competing interpretations of the events you just read about in the timeline. Even though both accounts agree that the massacres of the Ottoman Armenians did take place, they disagree on the case of whether or not these massacres should be deemed genocide. A summary of the two main interpretations is presented in the table below.
|Genocide Believers||Genocide Deniers|
|Genocide Believers||Genocide Deniers|
|Declare that genocide did occur because the Young Turk Triumvirate conducted the massacres and deportations systematically and with the intention of exterminating the entire Armenian ethnic population.||Proclaim genocide did not occur because the Young Turk Triumvirate was rationally responding to Armenian rebellions, which were supported by the Allied Powers and threatened the dissolution of the entire Ottoman Empire.|
Both views have found a place in separate historical narratives that vow to disprove the other. The former supported by the Armenian population, while the latter, by the Turkish government. Whichever historiography other countries choose to acknowledge greatly depends on how they recognize the genocide. Although international recognition for the Armenian genocide is growing, there are still a large number of countries that do not officially recognize the events of 1915 as genocidal. Before we decide how to personally and individually recognize the genocide, let’s first take the time to give the issue a more thorough examination by consulting primary and secondary sources.
Timeline of the Armenian Genocide
|Year||Events in History|
|Year||Events in History|
|1502||›Historical Armenia falls under Ottoman control and the millet system (the separate legal courts pertaining to "personal law" under which communities (Muslim Sharia, Christian Canon law and Jewish Halakha law abiding) were allowed to rule themselves under their own system.) is implemented there. Relatively peaceful relations between the Turks and minority groups, including the Armenians.|
|1860-1865||›Sublime Porte raises taxes to exorbitant levels. ›Constitutionalism spreads throughout Europe. ›Armenians begin to protest for equal citizenship and are violently subdued by Ottoman troops. ›Some Armenians begin to seek refuge in Europe and North America.|
|1876||›Abdul Hamid II becomes Sultan of the Ottoman Empire and severely oppresses any sign of civil disobedience.|
|1877-1878||›The already deteriorating Ottoman Empire is defeated in the Russo-Turkish War and experiences substantial territorial losses from the Balkans after signing the Treaty of Berlin.|
|1880-1890||›Thousands of Muslims from the Balkans seek refuge in the Ottoman Empire. ›Living conditions in the Empire decrease, while taxes rise.›Rise of the Armenian middle class in the Empire. ›Ottoman Armenians organize politically and receive support from Eastern Armenians under Russian control.|
|1892-1896||›Armenian political parties encourage Armenians to boycott taxes, post placards in Anatolia decrying the corrupt Sultan, and take over Bank Ottoman to gain international awareness of the Armenian massacres. ›Hamidian Massacres: Hamidiye troops suppress Armenian efforts encouraged by their parties, and kill approximately 200,000 Armenians. ›International community sends humanitarian aid to Armenians.|
|1908-1909||›The Young Turk Committee of Union and Progress overthrow Sultan and form a constitutional government. ›Armenian Bishop Mushegh declares the end of Armenian servitude and need to protect their new rights. 30,000 Armenians are massacred in response to the Bishop’s words. ›An attempt to restore the Sultan’s power fails.|
|1913||›Mehmed Talaat, Ismail Enver, and Ahmed Djemal organize a military coup, assassinating the leaders of the liberal and progressive branches of the Young Turk Revolution and consolidate power themselves, forming an ultranationalist Young Turk triumvirate.|
|1914||›The Sublime Porte decides to join the side of the Central Powers (Germany, Austro-Hungary) during the outbreak of the First World War.|
|Under the Young Turk Triumvirate (1913-1918)||›Armenian businesses, houses, and monasteries looted and some destroyed. ›Turkish males drafted for war and arms distributed to Muslim residents, while Armenian soldiers disarmed and sent to labour camps. ›Armenian political and intellectual figures arrested and murdered. ›Of the 2 million Armenians in the Ottoman Empire, hundreds of thousands of Armenians are deported and over a million are killed.|
|1915||›After reports from various embassies in the Ottoman Empire, the Allies warn the Sublime Porte that they will be held responsible for any crimes against the Armenians.|
|1918-1919||›Russian troops pull out of Eastern Armenia after a Russian revolution and Armenian leaders declare an Armenian Republic on May 28, 1918. ›Armistice signed at Mudros, ending the war between Turks and Allies. ›Triumvirate flees the Empire and Young Turk government dissolved. ›New Ottoman government supported by the Allies initiates court martial proceedings against triumvirate and other top officials.|
|1920-1923||›Mustafa Kemal forms an opposition party and invades the Armenian Republic with the support of Turkish troops. The Armenian Republic sacrifices independence and turns to Communist Russia for support. ›Court martial proceedings suspended as Kemalist movement spreads. ›Treaty of Lausanne dissolves Ottoman Empire and recognizes a new Turkish Republic under Kemal. Treaty fails to mention the Armenians.|
Permission granted - Armenian Genocide Museum
Asking these types of questions can help us understand how decisions about what to include or not include in these histories are made and in turn can help lead us to make our own critical and informed decisions on how we ourselves will choose to remember the Armenian Genocide.
Credit: AGBU archives, Vartan Derunian. This work was created in Syria and is now in the public domain there because its term of copyright has expired pursuant to the provisions of Law No. 12/2001, Syria's first ever copyright law. In order to be hosted on Commons, all works must be in the public domain in the United States as well as in their source country. Syrian works are currently in the public domain in the United States if their copyright had expired in Syria on the date of restoration (June 11, 2004).
"Persecution of Armenians assuming unprecedented proportions. Reports from widely scattered districts indicate systematic attempt to uproot peaceful Armenian populations and through arbitrary arrests, terrible tortures, whole-sale expulsions and deportations from one end of the Empire to the other accompanied by frequent instances of rape, pillage, and murder, turning into massacre, to bring destruction and destitution (hardship; poverty) on them. These measures are not in response to popular or fanatical (obsessive) demand but are purely arbitrary and directed from (the Sublime Porte in) Constantinople in the name of military necessity, often in districts where no military operations are likely to take place... there seems to be a systematic plan to crush the Armenian race."
Source: Power, Samantha. A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide. New York: Perennial, 2003.
"I admit that we deported many Armenians ...but we never acted in this matter upon a previously prepared scheme. The responsibility for these acts falls first of all upon the deported people themselves. Russia, in order to lay hand on our eastern provinces, has armed and equipped Armenian(s) and organized strong Armenian bandit forces...(that began) blowing up the bridges, setting fire to the Turkish towns and villages...and endangered the Turkish Army’s line of retreat...Every Armenian Church, it was later discovered, was a depot of ammunition. In this disloyal way they killed more than 300,000 (Muslims)...
It was impossible to shut our eyes to the treacherous acts of the Armenians, at a time when we were engaged in a war which would determine the fate of our country. Even if these atrocities had occurred in a time of peace, our Government would have been obliged to quell such outbreaks. The (Sublime) Porte...wishing to secure the safety of its army and its citizens, took energetic measures to check these uprisings...
These preventative measures were taken in every country during the war, but, while the regrettable results were passed over in silence in the other countries, the echo of our acts was heard all over the world."
Source: The Armenian Genocide in Perspective. Ed. Richard G. Hovannisian. New Brunswick: Transaction, 1986.
"Gradually we got news that Turks wanted to finish off all Armenians... we had secret meetings to figure out when this was going to happen and how we could prepare to resist and defend ourselves”
"We children used to go from house to house to gather brass candle bars to make shells for the bullets... The Turks had all the ammunition and ours was very limited, so we had to be very careful not to waste any."
Russian forces came to support the Armenians in Van in late April and the Turks retreated until 1918, when they eventually gained control of the province.
Source: Miller, D.E., and L.T. Miller’s Survivors: An Oral History of the Armenian Genocide. Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1993.
Photo from Genocide Resources
Source: Facing History And Ourselves.
"All able-bodied men were sorted out with the excuse that they were going to be given work. The women and children were sent ahead under escort ...The men kept behind were taken out of town in batches of 15 and 20, lined up on the edge of ditches (and) shot. After plundering and committing ...outrages on the women and children, they (the “shotas”) massacred (many) them. The military escorts had strict orders not to interfere with the “Shotas.”
“They had been on the road for three to five months; they have been plundered several times over, and have marched along naked and starving, the Government gave them on one single occasion a morsel of bread— a few had it twice. It is said that the number of these deported widows will reach 60, 000; they are so exhausted they cannot stand upright; the majority have great sores on their feet, through having to march barefoot”
Source: Miller, D.E., and L.T. Miller’s Survivors: An Oral History of the Armenian Genocide.
|List of Countries that Officially Recognize the Armenian Genocide, 2013|
|List of Countries that Officially Recognize the Armenian Genocide, 2013|
Source: Armenian Genocide.
"There has not been a genocide and if people for political motivations want to use (recognize) it ... they take the risk of influencing their relationships with Turkey”
"History suggests to us that if we are to survive and keep up our national identity, we need strength and a fighting spirit...We need nationwide solidarity and unity to make our Cause (sic) heard in any part of the globe.”
Source: BBC Documentary, “The Betrayed,” (2003) and Armenian Genocide Victims
"A person who publicly denigrates (insults) the Turkish Nation... shall be punishable by imprisonment of between six months and two years"
“A person who publicly denigrates the Government of the Republic of Turkey, the judicial institution...the military or security organizations shall be ...(imprisoned for) six months to two years.”
As Taner Akcam, a Turkish historian explains, the law has been used against numerous intellectuals in Turkey, including himself, who chose to use the term, “genocide” to describe and discuss the events of 1915.
Source: PBS Documentary, “The Armenian Genocide.” 2006.
In December 2008, a number of Turkish intellectuals, politicians, and journalists came together to start the I Apologize campaign in Turkey. The campaign allows Turkish citizens to individually and personally apologize for the atrocities against the Armenians by adding their name to an online form under the following statement:
“My conscience does not accept the insensitivity showed to and the denial of the Great Catastrophe that the Ottoman Armenians were subjected to in 1915. I reject this injustice and for my share, I empathize with the feelings and pain of my Armenian brothers and sisters. I apologize to them.” *
*The list of names of those who signed the online petition displayed below the statement.
The campaign website can be viewed here: http://bit.ly/armenians1915.
So far, of Turkey's population (approximately 76,000,000 in 2012), almost 32,500 have signed the campaign.
Independently identify at least three factors that distinguish between the concept of “the past” and “history.”
A. Compare and contrast your ideas from Task One. Be sure to discuss any similarities or differences of opinion you may have.
B. Discuss the following questions:
Source: This Minds On Activity was adapted from: Denos, Mike and Roland Case, Teaching about Historical Thinking. Ed. Peter Seixas and Penney Clark. Vancouver: The Critical Thinking Consortium, 2006.
B. In Henry Morgenthau’s cable to Washington, he speaks of a “systematic plan to crush the Armenian race”. Does Morgenthau have reason to make this claim? Please explain your answer using the timeline provided and Artifacts One to Seven.
C. Did these artifacts influence your understanding of the Armenian Genocide? Explain how or how not? Are you left with any questions or concerns? If so please write them down for future discussion.
D. Why do you think only ten percent of the world officially recognizes the Armenian genocide? What do you think influences a country’s choice of whether or not to recognize genocide? Think politically, socially, economically, and geographically.
E. Why is gaining genocide recognition so important to Armenians? Please explain your reasoning.
F. On the other hand, why do you think the Turkish government is so reluctant to call the events of 1915 “a genocide”?
A. To what extent does this campaign make a difference? Do you think it helps reconcile the relationship between Turkish and Armenian peoples? Explain.
B. Would you sign a similar campaign commemorating the genocide against the Armenians? Now that you’re more informed, how has your opinion changed about this horrific genocide?
Read the article “Armenians in Canada.”
Every effort has been made to copyright holders for permission to reproduce borrowed material. The publishers apologize for such omissions and will be pleased to rectify them in subsequent reprints and website programming.